COMPARE YOUR OPTIONS
Find the Right Roofing Material for Your Property
Compare natural cedar shake, slate, clay and concrete tile, and synthetic roofing based on appearance, weight, maintenance, and performance.
Start With What Matters Most
There is no single best roof for every property. The right choice depends on the building, the look you want, and how you want the roof to perform.
Cedar Shake
Cedar shake is a strong choice for homeowners who want an authentic material that develops character over time.
- Natural wood material
- Rich texture and variation
- Available with fire-retardant treatment
- Requires routine maintenance
Natural Slate
Real stone roofing with a distinctive appearance and an exceptionally long service life when properly installed and maintained.
- Genuine stone material
- Timeless, high-end appearance
- Long-lasting performance
- Requires proper structural support
Clay & Concrete Tile
Tile roofing adds strong architectural detail and is available in a wide range of profiles, finishes, and colors.
- Distinctive shapes and colors
- Clay and concrete options
- Durable and weather-resistant
- Roof structure must be evaluated
Synthetic Roofing
Premium synthetic roofing creates the appearance of natural cedar or slate while offering a lighter-weight and simpler upkeep.
- Natural-looking profiles
- Lighter than many natural materials
- Low-maintenance option
- Strong fire and impact protection options
Compare Your Options
The best material depends on the property, roof structure, selected product, and project goals. Our team will inspect the roof and explain which options are suitable.
| Roofing Material | Appearance | Weight | Maintenance | Important Features | Fire Protection |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Natural Cedar Shake | Authentic wood with natural texture and variation | Moderate | Regular Care | Weather naturally and can be repaired in sections | Fire-retardant protects and rated roof systems are available |
| Natural Slate | Genuine stone with distinctive color and character | Heavy | Low, with specialized repairs | Exceptionally long-lasting when properly installed | Naturally noncombustible |
| Clay & Concrete Tile | Available in flat, S-tile, barrel, and custom profiles | Heavy | Low | Durable, weather-resistant, and available in many colors | Noncombustible; Class A systems are available |
| Synthetic Shake | Designed to recreate hand-split cedar | Lightweight | Low | Resists splitting, rotting, curling, and insect damage | Class A fire rating |
| Synthetic Slate | Designed to recreate natural quarried slate | Lightweight | Low | Consistent sizing with a wide range of colors and blends | Class A fire rating |
Swipe to compare
The Short Version
Choose Natural When…
- Authentic wood, stone, or clay matters most
- You prefer natural color and texture variation
- The material works with the property’s architecture
- The roof can support the selected material
- You are comfortable with material-specific care
Choose Synthetic When…
- You want the appearance of shake or slate
- A lighter roofing material is preferred
- You want less routine maintenance
- You prefer more consistent color and sizing
- Fire and impact resistance are priorities
Still Not Sure?
Every property is different. We can evaluate your roof, compare suitable materials, and show you actual colors and profiles.
Shake, Slate & Tile
Specialty roofing by All American Exterior Solutions.
Hours
Monday-Friday
8:00 AM-5:00 PM